...so I am still pondering the new world of L&D and the role of AI.
AI changes the economics of producing many of the things that have traditionally defined our work. It can generate a course outline, write a draft, produce a quiz, create scenarios, summarize information, and help assemble learning materials at a speed that would have been difficult to imagine just a few years ago. The output may need considerable review and revision, but the barrier to producing something that looks like a finished product has dropped considerably.
So: If producing the deliverable becomes easier, what happens to the value of the expertise that goes into deciding what the deliverable should be? I remember writing years about about the fact that often something we have accomplished likely took "half an hour plus the rest of our lives up till now."
I don't think the answer is to abandon instructional design or stop making things. Rather, I think we need to pay much more attention to the parts of our work that have always mattered but haven't been especially visible. What did we notice that prompted us to take a different direction? Why did we decide a course wasn't the right answer? What did we learn from talking with employees? Which assumptions did we challenge? What trade-offs did we consider? How did we arrive at a recommendation, and what happened as a result?
These are not incidental activities surrounding the "real" work. THEY ARE THE WORK.
AI introduces an interesting possibility here, too. It can help lower the cost of making work visible. Rough notes from a conversation can become a useful summary. A collection of observations can be organized into patterns. A series of decisions can be turned into a record that others can follow. AI can help us communicate and document work that might otherwise remain scattered across notebooks, inboxes, meeting transcripts, and individual memories.
Of course, making something visible doesn't automatically make it meaningful or credible. AI can produce a polished explanation of a decision without having any knowledge of what actually happened. The value is in connecting what we share to real work, real decisions, and real consequences. The technology can help us tell the story, but we still have to supply the substance.
I began thinking about a different kind of professional portfolio, too. Not one that consists primarily of samples of courses, presentations, and other finished deliverables, but one that makes professional thinking visible. What did you notice? What questions did you ask? What did you recommend, and why? What did you decide not to do? What changed as a result of your involvement?
This is a different way of thinking about evidence of expertise. A polished deliverable can show that you know how to make something. It tells us considerably less about how you think, how you exercise judgment, or how you work through ambiguity.
I realized I'm not just interested in helping L&D practitioners become more visible. I want to help them recognize, articulate, and demonstrate the expertise that was already present in their work, much of which had been obscured by a profession that had come to measure itself by what it produced.
The work behind the work deserves to be seen.The organizations that hire us need to understand what expertise looks like, where it resides, and what it makes possible.